I think that it is easy to see Rosalie and Emmett’s relationship as superficial and only physical, but it is much more than that. Their relationship is described as mainly physical, but I think that this is the area of their relationship they feel the most secure in, not the only part of their relationship. In Eclipse when they are fighting the newborns and there is a comment about how Jasper tried to fight off too many newborns so that Alice wouldn’t have to fight and Bella makes Edward not fight for fear of losing him. I do not think that Emmett and Rosalie don’t care enough to worry about the other dyeing, but they are so confidant in their physical abilities that they see no need to worry. Rosalie knows that if she is in trouble Emmett with come to save her, but at the same time Emmett knows Rosalie can hold her own. And then in the New Moon extra, Miscalculation when Rosalie messes up and realizes what has happened she screams for Emmett because she needs him emotionally then.
I feel that Rose would give up everything to have a child even Emmett and her family. I find that a little selfish. I belive that Emmett would walk through fire for her but I don't think that she would do the same for him. Yes she loves him but I don't think she really loves him. Yes, she may love Emmett, I think that she's really in love with him and the sad part is that Emmett knows that if she was given her human life back and to never have known her vampire life then she would do it. by skylarblue
I finished re-reading New Moon again last night and in the 'voting' chapter I once felt extremly sorry for Emmet. When Rosalie points out that 'she wished someone voted no for her'. by Lieziewiezie
I don’t think that it is fair to say that Rosalie would give Emmett up for human life just because in New Moon she says that she wishes someone where there to vote no for her. I think that she is saying that Bella has a chance to stay human and be with Edward. Now that Rosalie has fallen in love with Emmett I don’t think she would give him up. Saying that Emmett would do anything for Rose but she wouldn’t return the favor isn’t fair either; I think she loves him more than she lets on. She defiantly wants a child, but she wants Emmett’s child. Rosalie said how she wanted a family, but I don’t think that she would find being a single mother ideal. She wants the whole package, but since she already has Emmett she doesn’t go around talking about how much she wants a man that she loves. It is true even for humans, we don’t go around saying we want things we already have, and when there is something we want but can’t have the more we want it.