The Dark Knight wrote:Eclipse is my favorite book, if Midnight Sun ever get finished it will likely take the top spot. Followed by Twilight, Breaking Dawn. I am not a fan of New moon...
mixie wrote:Gahh this is really a hard one to anwer.. I just love all of the books!
Twilight - Because we get introduced to the love between E&B and it's just so sweet. Reading it made me want to find my own Edward. I think it's the one which mostly is about Bella and Edward before all the magic stuff. It's just the greatest love story ever written, it beats titanic and romeo&juliet by miles!
New Moon - This book is the most heartbreaking in the saga. I cried so much when Edward left and really suffered with Bella the whole time he was gone. I'm 100% Team-Edward so I didn't really like all the Jacob stuff, but I guess that's the point cause you truly understand Bella and how much she misses Edward. Also, the end is one of my favorite parts in the whole saga. I love the line "Before you my life was..". Give me Edward!
Eclipse - I like Eclipse because of the development of E&B's relationship. I think it really gets serious during the book. It also includes many of my favorite quotes and of course the proposal. But I'm having a really hard time with the end. I hate the Jacob part when Bella realizes that she loves him. I just can't understand that she really thinks about being with him, after everything she and Edward have gone through. I hate to see how it hurts Edward and how truly and deeply he loves her, so much that he's even ready to let her go. I was so angry reding this.
Breaking Dawn - During the two first book (Bella's and Jacob's) I was so confused. Everything was so different and I didn't really like it. The feeling between Edward and Bella had changed so much and it wasn't as sweet as before. But I loved it after Bella was transformed, I always wanted her to become a vampire! Yes, it changed everything betwwen E&B, but it didn't get worse. At first, I didn' like Nessie cause came between E&B and took all of Bella's attention but, like everyone else, I just couldn't resist falling for her. And she actually made the band between E&B even stronger. Another reason why I like Nessie is because Jacob imprinted on her. The one thing in the saga that always bothered me was Jacob and Bella's feelings for him. Now that he got his own happy ending and didn't try to distroy E&B's relationship I could finally enjoy Jacob. He really is a crack-up! I liked the ending too, and the fact that it didn't turn into a fight. I didn't want the Twilight saga to be a fantasy story with all the supernational stuff, because I think it's mainly a love story. And I really think E&B deserved to get their happily ever after, they really went to hell and back to get eachother!
But if I have to choose I think I would pick Twilight and BD.. Or NM hehe
edwardsblossom wrote:The Dark Knight wrote:Eclipse is my favorite book, if Midnight Sun ever get finished it will likely take the top spot. Followed by Twilight, Breaking Dawn. I am not a fan of New moon...
What exactly don't you like New Moon? I'm sure there are plenty of reasons, but I'm curious.
Dovrebanen wrote:New Moon is my favorite book because of the sacrifice that Edward makes when he leaves. The leaving scene and when he tells her that he doesn't want her, and it actually makes perfect sense to Bella. The first time through I was frantic and desperate to get Edward back. But now I enjoy all parts of it. The way Bella is around Jacob is also proof of her love for Edward. We get to see her trying to regain some strenght, and realizing that there is only one thing she needs. And we see that Edward is with Bella all the way, always in her heart. And from Italy and onwards, like Jade said, is just perfect. It is where they see that they can't be without each other and that they will make it work somehow. It's a perfect book.
I also like it because it gives Bella the chance to show some strength. She gets to be the one to save Edward instead of being the damsel in distress. It turns the power balance a bit in their relationship IMO.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests