Dark_Heart wrote:You all make wonderful points... but isn't the reason Bella was so reckless so she could "hear" Edwards "voice?"
She may have been carefree around Jacob, but she was way more secure with Edward. On top of that, she was still recovering from Edward, even though she never really did. She never really had to, actually. Besides that, once Edward's voice started to fade away, she started getting more reckless to bring it back. She wasn't trying to kill herself when she jumped off the cliff... Although she did come close... She was trying to hear Edward again. So.... Bella + Edward = PERFECT
Jacob is just another annoying side character until the fourth book... at which point Bella tries to kill him... LMAO. Best part of the series, that.
navarre wrote:Okay everyone, I have a question. Now, if this has been asked in an earlier post in this thread, please forgive me. I'm lazy and did not want to scroll through 90+ pages to see.
In my local paper is a huge article on the film Twilight. In this article a girl made the comment that she sees Edward & Bella's relationship realistically and feels that Bella was never her true self with Edward - that she had to always act & be perfect for Edward to love her. She also stated that Bella acted herself with Jacob and could be herself with Jacob.
Naturally I disagree. I think Edward accepted Bella 100% and I do not feel that he demanded Bella to be perfect for him. I basically feel this is self explanatory but what do you lovely darlings think?
holdingoutforjacob wrote:i think edward dazzles bella. if anything i think she is least comfortable around him, because she is so insecure with him, up until she becomes a vampire.
aimee_xbella wrote:I like Bella/Edward better than Bella/Jacob. Jacob's relationship with Bella seems relatively more "normal" if you want to call it that. To me, it's just more realistic. However, I'd rather believe in the fairytale or "vampire tale" =p. It just gives me the sensation of magic. I can read about a guy that has Jacob's personalities in a lot of other YA books, so I guess it doesn't appeal to me.
I think that to Edward, Bella is perfect even though she might not think so herself. The cool thing about that is that Edward is exactly the same way! If you have read Midnight Sun, you would know how Edward despise himself a lot of times, but on the other hand, Bella thinks Edward is absolutely perfect. And this is why they both are perfect for each other.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest