Moonlit Sunlight wrote:yeah i agree... even Jacob who hated the vampires had a hard time trying to hate Carlisle... and i mean he's so charasmatic and sweet.... but if i was the bad guy i would also be scared of Carlisle... i mean i think he could be a really scary vampire if he wanted to be one.... and Pete Facinellie was great as Carlisle.. he portrayed him very well and i though he looked great with Esme.
Hmmm.... Interesting thought, Moonlit Sunlight. I don't know if I could ever be scared of Carlisle. I mean, we know he defends Bella against James & crew in Twilight. We know he fights the newborns in Eclipse. And, we know he's prepared to fight the Volturi in BD, if it had been necessary. But, in each of those situations, it was totally as a last resort. I have always found Carlisle so reassuring and gentle. I don't think I could ever be scared of him. Even with the "bad guys", look at how he handles Bella's attackers, or lead attacker, in MS. He drugs the guy and leaves him in front of a police station. And, we know how well Edward explained exactly what a lowlife scum he was. Carlisle truly abhores the thought of violence of any kind. He's a rare individual.