Re: Leah Clearwater
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 5:50 pm
Ok so just to try and make some peace here
*Waves a white flag*
Leah seems to be a heated discussion, some of you love her some of you hate her. A bit like marmite (It's a British spread before you ask).
Bkwrm -Yeah it does suck that Sam imprinted on Emily. And perhaps it was a bit stupid for Emily to ask Leah to be a bridesmaid, but can I point out that someone else asked someone to be the best man. Emily was trying to be nice. Sam was the one who imprinted on Emily, and like Jacob said it's hard to resist that kind of devotion. I agree however that Leah does have issues that perhaps she should talk about instead of shouting about, but that's just her.
Holdingoutforjacob- wouldn't you whine if the thing you loved was killing you? Plus she still liked Jacob (in a way). I agree that Bella deserved to be told how she was messing around Jacob, it brings her back to reality. I pretty much side with you on this whole "argument" but I don't think you should have made that comment about reading the books. It sounds like Bkwrm likes Bella. So she does like someone.
Please ignore me if I'm being whiny and annoying, I just think certain arguments are fertile, after all we all love the same thing. It's a bit like a civil war, don’t you think? However if I'm being an idiot I apologize, I have a tendency to meddle, sorry
Finally my opinion? Well like I said before, I loved Leah, even if she is bitter and twisted at times, her friendship seems to become genuine with Jacob and she, at sometimes seems to want to protect Jacob. I like that about her.
Once again sorry, I just thought this needed a bit of a cooling down period.
Anyone for tea?
*Waves a white flag*
Leah seems to be a heated discussion, some of you love her some of you hate her. A bit like marmite (It's a British spread before you ask).
Bkwrm -Yeah it does suck that Sam imprinted on Emily. And perhaps it was a bit stupid for Emily to ask Leah to be a bridesmaid, but can I point out that someone else asked someone to be the best man. Emily was trying to be nice. Sam was the one who imprinted on Emily, and like Jacob said it's hard to resist that kind of devotion. I agree however that Leah does have issues that perhaps she should talk about instead of shouting about, but that's just her.
Holdingoutforjacob- wouldn't you whine if the thing you loved was killing you? Plus she still liked Jacob (in a way). I agree that Bella deserved to be told how she was messing around Jacob, it brings her back to reality. I pretty much side with you on this whole "argument" but I don't think you should have made that comment about reading the books. It sounds like Bkwrm likes Bella. So she does like someone.
Please ignore me if I'm being whiny and annoying, I just think certain arguments are fertile, after all we all love the same thing. It's a bit like a civil war, don’t you think? However if I'm being an idiot I apologize, I have a tendency to meddle, sorry
Finally my opinion? Well like I said before, I loved Leah, even if she is bitter and twisted at times, her friendship seems to become genuine with Jacob and she, at sometimes seems to want to protect Jacob. I like that about her.
Once again sorry, I just thought this needed a bit of a cooling down period.
Anyone for tea?