Amanda Beth wrote:As a sidenote, I was wondering if say in a different world where Edward wasn't the factor he is, if Bella would be able to comfortably fall for Jake knowing that his imprint could come along at any time. I know Jake thought of Bella like she WAS his imprting, but she's obviously not. Could you love someone who by good chance may at any time fall in love with someone else? I couldn't.
swedishskinjer wrote:Jacob, despite his best attempts to delude himself, was not meant for Bella, since an imprinting never happened until he glimpsed Renesmee, who was a "part" of his friend that he could watch over due to her intimate bonding with Edward. They are the closest of friends imaginable, considering that Jacob healed her "hole" during Edward's regrettable absence, but he pursued a higher relationship with Bella that was not meant for him. As she said when Jacob insisted on repeatedly crossing a line with their relationship, it was always meant to be Edward since her first step into his world. Bella's belief that she is irrevocably linked with Edward is only validated when she feels his overwhelming love for her as an immortal companion.
swedishskinjer wrote:I know that some fans find a relationship between Bella and Jacob preferable, despite the fact that he is not human (like Edward, of course), but that's not the true love story in this series. It has always been about the forbidden love between Bella and Edward and all of the adventures that have followed. With the improbable birth of Renesmee, Jacob was able to embrace an extension of Bella, so he was not deprived of a happy ending. It's undeniable that things did work out, but not exactly in the way that he anticipated: for Jacob, a new destiny was revealed, hence the imprinting and his subsequent bonding with Renesmee, who is so much more than your average child. If you believe that destiny works its mysterious ways in the Twilight series, then you should be able to acknowledge that the pairing between Jacob and Renesmee was supposed to happen, as opposed to Jacob and Bella (who was meant to be with the Cullen family).
swedishskinjer wrote:Jacob Black was always destined to be the close friend, but Bella's deepest feelings belong exclusively to Edward Cullen.
swedishskinjer wrote:When some fans say that Bella can't have any fun around the Cullen family, I simply have to shake my head. Some of the funniest moments in the series would have to be the sarcastic conversations between Bella and Edward. Furthermore, a few of the most energetic characters in the entire saga are Alice and Emmett "Big Bear" Cullen, who happily embraced Bella as their sibling after the transformation. Also: VAMPIRE BASEBALL!
holdingoutforjacob wrote:Oh absolutely that's why she feels insecure around him - but she's uncomfortable, nonetheless.
How about we get back to the discussion about Jacob though - or maybe we should switch the forums, since we just had this discussion in the Bella thread!!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests