Twilight Lexicon Discussion Forums

1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?
I'm a huge fan of Linkin Park. I've liked them from the first CD on. So, I like Phil's taste in music

2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?
No, I didn't feel she was in danger.

3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?
No, not really.

4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?
Not at the moment, but I did note that she felt watched, so I did think that later on in the book.

5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?
No.

1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?
I like older Linkin Park music not to crazy about some of their new stuff. I thought that Phil was an ok guy since he was trying to reach out to Bella.

2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?
I wasn't too sure yet but I had decided that the danger was NOT from Edward already

3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?
A little because she is such a Klutz, I wondered if she had a sense of direction or not and doubted that she did have.

4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?
I wasn't thinking along those lines yet no.

5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?
Not really

1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?

I love linkin park! They are one of my favorite bands! I can't wait for their new album comming out in September! I want to know which Linkin Park cd Bella was listening to. I think Phil must have good taste in music and is probably one of those adults who are are more open to modern day rock rather thank just sticking to the classic rock in their own generation.

2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?

Yeah I thought she was in danger from an unknown source.


3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?

Yeah I was nervous that she would get lost and not know her way back home.

4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?

No I wasn't even thinking that.

5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?

Renee seemed more paranoid and unreasonable about Bella not answering her e-mails. I didn't understand why she didn't just call Bella since that would of been a faster way to reach her. I think she wants to be a part of Bella's life and just doesn't realize that she hovers too much. Charlie seemed like he was paying a little less attension to Bella than usual.

1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?

I think that Linkin Park has some good songs, but some of them are annoying. I think that Phil's taste in music is fine, though not quite my thing. On a side note, I wonder how Bella was able to fall asleep while listening to them... It would have been far too noisy for me.

2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?

I think she was in more danger from the wolf than Edward. I think she had a part in her mind that trusted that Edward wouldn't hurt her, somehow.

3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?

Yeah, a little. That certainly isn't something that I would do.

4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?

He might have been, but he was probably watching through the window. If Bella was still awake, I don't know if Edward would have been in her room with her.

5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?

Nah, not really.

1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?
Not a fan, I hate to say. My tastes run more toward country, jazz, and oldies.

2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?
I didn't feel she was in direct danger, but I did think that being between the wolf and Edward might have put her in danger.

3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?
A little, after all, it's Bella.

4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?
No, I think of that at all.

5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?
No, and I don't think they have even into the present.

1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?
I don't particularly like them, but horses for courses.

2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?
Her imagination.

3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?
No. Maybe I should have been.

4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?
Not at first.

5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?
No.

Alphie wrote:1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?

Nothing wrong with Linkin Park. I don't really like to judge musical tastes.

Alphie wrote:2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?

Seemed like she was in danger from Edward.

Alphie wrote:3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?

I never even thought of this scene as scary until I read this question.

Alphie wrote:4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?

Didn't even cross my mind.

Alphie wrote:5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?

No, not really.

1. The music group that Bella falls asleep listening to has been revealed by Stephenie to be Linkin Park. What do you think of Linkin Park, and about Phil's taste in music since he gave Bella the CD?

Cool since I am a fan of Linkin Park.

2. In Bella's nightmare, did you think Bella was in danger, if so from whom?

No I didn't think she was in danger. I just thought she was having nightmares to the possibility of them being vampires.

3. Were you at all nervous when Bella decided to take a walk in the woods alone?

I didn't really feel she was in danger. The woods just seem spooky b/c of old stories and we let our imaginations go wild in that surroundings.


4. Did you think Edward was watching Bella as she fell asleep reading Jane Austen?

Not when I read it a few times but I did wonder after the 2nd reading. It wasn't till I read the book that shall not be named that answered that question for me.

5. Did your impressions of Renee and Charlie change at all this chapter?

I think her parents needed to be more in her life. It always bothered me why Renee would email her daughter than pick up the phone. As a mom I want to hear my children's voices than a quiet email.