Twilight Lexicon Discussion Forums

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book? I had no clue at this point. I knew that they weren't traditional werewolves, being turned into one by being bitten and then transforming at the full moon. Shape-shifters didn't even dawn on me until I read it in Breaking Dawn! Sometimes I can be so daft!

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
I did. When Bella had that dream after the bonfire, I started to worry.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt? Did he and Edward plan on him just to hide and then help? Did I miss that?

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth? She definitely would have drawn blood in order to help- no doubt about that!

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?

I really had no clue.

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?

Pretty much, Bella always tries to sacrifice herself for everyone. Just look at Twilight, with her going to sacrifice herself for Renee, and then in NM when she was going to sacrifice herself for edward. Of course she was going to do it again.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?

I figured he was supposed to run to stay safe. I was completly clueless at that point. Now I see I was just being dumb lmao. Of course Edward and seth had it planned out lol Seth would want to fight.

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?

Probably would have killed herself. She has shown she is willing to do that already in other books. She will die to protect those she loves.

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?
I didn't understand it, so it kind of sailed over my head.

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
I kind of thought it would become a little more important after learning that she had talked about it in her sleep, but before that, no.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?
I think it was a very clever ruse, a nice strategy.

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?
She would have died to save them. That's obvious just from having read Twilight... she'd die to save Edward any day of the week.

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?
I was not too surprised. These books have thrown so many curve balls at all of us that when shocking things happen now I just go with the flow. Now, Breaking Dawn on the other hand was a completley different story, I did not see that coming (I don't want to give anything away in case someone hasn't read it since this is the Eclipse forum)!

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
YES! It screamed Bella as soon as I heard the legend.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?
I thought that he was supposed to stay away and run so that he wouldn't get hurt.

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?
I think that she would have cut herself and done anything else that she could have done that she thought would help save them...wow, I hope that makes sense!

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?

I was thinking: 'what the heck are you talking about boy'.

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
I figured it would in some way.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?

I think at some point while they were gone when Bella and Jake were talking, they talked strategies and Edward insisted that Seth would run, but Seth didn't agree.

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?

She might have just stuck the darn rock into some place other than her arm.

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?
That still confuses me. What did Edward mean?

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
Yes, because of Bella's reactions to the story. I knew something was going to happen.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?
I have no idea.

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?
I think she would have killed herself.

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?
I didn't think much of it, I was too caught up in the story. after reading the end of breaking dawn though, i kind of understand the difference.

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
Yes, it is something i could easily see bella doing.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?
I didn't think much of it, and i didnt understand what was going on, but im glad seth came back to help

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?
She would have done everything she could have, that is just who she is.

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?
I am still not sure what James tracked through Siberia.

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
Nope.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?
I still don't know why Edward told Seth to run.

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?
I think she would have died and happily, to save them.

1. Edward asks Victoria if Seth is like the monster that James tracked through Sibera. What did you think about that the first time you read the book?
-OH MY GOD ! I WAS SO CONFUSED WHEN I READ THAT! It bugged me FOREVER until I read somewhere online what it meant haha.

2. When you first heard the Quilete’s legend about the 3rd wife, did you anticipate it coming into play like this?
-No, not at first. When Bella started thinking about it more often and dreaming about it though, I was starting to wonder if it was more important then I thought.

3. When Edward tells Seth to run, did you think they planned he would hide in the shadows and help or did you think he was supposed to stay away as to not get hurt?
-No ! I thought Edward was telling Seth to run away so he wouldn't get hurt. Very tricky ! haha.

4. If Bella’s sacrifice hadn’t have worked so quickly, how far do you think she would have gone to save Edward and Seth?
-Bella probably would've hurt herself pretty bad if it meant saving Edward and Seth. She can get kinda crazy when it comes to those things, not that thats bad though haha.