Besides personality, hair and the eyes are pretty important for me... I like guys with either dark brown hair, black hair, or a golden blond hair color. The hair can't be too short, yet long enough to do that hair flippy thing when your hair gets into your eyes... Eyes have to be the color of blue or brown. Green too, but mostly just blue or brown.
Being athletic isn't a must. He has to be tall (taller than me at least...). Intelligent is a definite. Kind. Mysterious, quiet. Musical is optional, but if he does play an instrument, I prefer piano. A sense of humor would be great, but he has to know when to be serious. He doesn't have to be muscular, I don't really like muscular guys much... Always honest.
Ha ha, typing all this down and reading what I had typed, I seem shallow