I'm sorry if this might not please some people, but after having read all four books now ( I don't put any spoilers here in case anybody hasn't finished it
), it is all the more difficult, almost impossible for me to imagine Robert as Edward. At first, I tried to imagine it and was like "Okay, guess he can make it", but now I'm not so sure about this anymore. I think he was a perfect Cedric, but EDWARD??
I still hope, though, that the movie proves the opposite when it finally comes in the movie theatres...
So let's wait and see!