Peter Facinelli as Carlisle Cullen

[lady4string]

I now think of Peter when I read Carlisle parts. I know some people complained that he was too old to play CC, but Peter looks 20-something anyway and they also needed someone who can portray a person who automatically oozes respect and authority. It's too bad his makeup sucked in Twilight and he's gotten stuck with a crappy wig for NM. Poor guy can't get a break when it comes to hair and makeup.

[Gen4Cullens]

So I'll have to say it...I never thought Peter Facinelli was anything super special, but as Carlisle...he's hot! The scene in NM where he is stiching Bella up in his study...omg...I totally saw him in a different way. I think his age isn't really a factor, because in the book, Carlisle is in his late 20's, and Peter appears young enough to pull it off in an authoritative way.
Love him!!

[SwanCullen]

I think he did great as Carlisle. He fit what I thought Carlisle to be. I do agree he is MUCh better looking in NM than Twilight.

[ash_luvs_carlisle]

a way to describe me feelings about peter facinelli and indeed carlisle cullen...
<3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 !!!

[ash_luvs_carlisle]

i completely agree he looks better i newmoon than twilight but he looks even more gorgeous in eclipse! sooo gorgeous! i envy jennie garth and elizabeth reaser!