Edward vs. Jacob Campaign!

[navarre]

Greetings!! topazeyes2 I'm navarre(Christy). Glad you could join our team.

Here's a Edward question:

In Eclipse, while Rosalie was telling Bella her story, Bella found Rosalie's world baffling and she wondered if her own world was as baffling to Edward. Do you think Bella's world WAS baffling to Edward?

[topazeyes2]

In Eclipse,while Rosalie was telling Bella her story, Bella found Rosalie's world baffling and she wondered if her own world was as baffling to Edward. Do you think Bella's world WAS bafflign to Edwards?
No, I think he had already lived in that time period for long enough he could probably guess her life especially since Bella's life was just the slightest bit predictable and monotonous before she met Edward.

[debussygirl]

In Eclipse, while Rosalie was telling Bella her story, Bella found Rosalie's world baffling and she wondered if her own world was as baffling to Edward. Do you think Bella's world WAS baffling to Edward? I don't think so, since he could grow with the times and hear other's thoughts as they progressed toward the present.

[Jasper<3]

In Eclipse, while Rosalie was telling Bella her story, Bella found Rosalie's world baffling and she wondered if her own world was as baffling to Edward. Do you think Bella's world WAS baffling to Edward?

Naw, Edward was around while the times were progressing, he was there for all the changes. If he was just dumped in the present, he may be a little mixed up, but he would ajust.

[-Jasper]

In Eclipse, while Rosalie was telling Bella her story, Bella found Rosalie's world baffling and she wondered if her own world was as baffling to Edward. Do you think Bella's world WAS baffling to Edward?

I don't think so, as Edward would have nearly 2 centuries of experience with life, and would find little baffling. Plus he can see how people think, so would know exactly what everyone meant and experienced.

[Jasper<3]

In Eclipse, while Rosalie was telling Bella her story, Bella found Rosalie's world baffling and she wondered if her own world was as baffling to Edward. Do you think Bella's world WAS baffling to Edward?

I don't think so, as Edward would have nearly 2 centuries of experience with life, and would find little baffling. Plus he can see how people think, so would know exactly what everyone meant and experienced.

That's exactly what I was getting at, Jenini just answered it better! <3

[threethings]

Welcome back Nat. We've been having E&J fun without you!

Anyway, that was a fabulous question Christy. Bravo!

Now, this has nothing to do with this thread at all, but I know you guys will help me and my buds.
So, me and the Taylor Team (The Taylor thread girls), do Obsessed. I'm sure you know this.
Anyway, it was nominated for a Dazzle award, and we need more people to nominate it agian and again.
Because the more it gets nominated, the higher chances it had in the final round.
So, if you all could go over to the Dazzle award site, and email them to nominate us again, I'll love you even more.
Here's Obsessed to check out
Here's info on nomination

We really appreciate anybody that does it! And here's a question to stay on topic:

If Jacob hadn't seen Renesmee after she was born, how long would it take Jacob to imprint on her?
I mean, think about it. Say Rosalie wasn't sitting on the couch, say Jacob jumped out the window or something.
He would go through all that pain for nothing. It could all be cured by simply seeing Renesmee. How would that play out?


Chloe

[navarre]

Welcome back Nat. We've been having E&J fun without you!

Anyway, that was a fabulous question Christy. Bravo!

Now, this has nothing to do with this thread at all, but I know you guys will help me and my buds.
So, me and the Taylor Team (The Taylor thread girls), do Obsessed. I'm sure you know this.
Anyway, it was nominated for a Dazzle award, and we need more people to nominate it agian and again.
Because the more it gets nominated, the higher chances it had in the final round.
So, if you all could go over to the Dazzle award site, and email them to nominate us again, I'll love you even more.
Here's Obsessed to check out
[url]Here's info on nomination[/url]

We really appreciate anybody that does it! And here's a question to stay on topic:

If Jacob hadn't seen Renesmee after she was born, how long would it take Jacob to imprint on her?
I mean, think about it. Say Rosalie wasn't sitting on the couch, say Jacob jumped out the window or something.
He would go through all that pain for nothing. It could all be cured by simply seeing Renesmee. How would that play out?


Chloe

My understanding from SM's website, that In Forever Dawn, Jacob would have imprinted on Renesmee three weeks later at Charlie's house. But, the relationship dynamic was written differently for Bella & Jacob. Their relationship never progressed past the crush stage because Edward never left. But I digress.

Probably if he had returned at some point to see what really happened; no funeral like he expected - Bella would be alive and not dead like he thought, then he would have seen the child and badda-bing - imprint.

[threethings]

Looks like we slowed down a little. . . so I'll pick it back up.

Here's a new question:

If Jacob were too never accept Bella as a vampire, how would his imprint-ation change?

-Chloe

[debussygirl]

If Jacob were too never accept Bella as a vampire, how would his imprint-ation change? Well, I don't think it would have changed, because as long as Bella was human, he would have fought for her. Then once she was a vampire, he would have seen Renesmee by then, and would have imprinted. Even if he still didn't approve Bella being a vampire, he would have to accept it for Renesmee's sake, or else he would lose her.