Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?

[marielle]

I'm so happy with everybody on Lex....
On other sites I have to defend Team Edward every 20 seconds or so..
Everybody swithed teams after seeing New Moon...

I only love Edward more after that...
now I crack up in tears while reading Jacobs part in BD, not because it's so sad for Jake but it is really sad for Edward..
He is watching his wife die and he can't do anything about it....

But I love you who stayed true to their team....( no mather if you are team Edward or Team Jacob, abs shouldn't make a difference!!!!!!)

Marielle~ Testify my sister, TESTIFY!!!

I have always been and will ALWAYS BE Edward's.

For me, it's the difference between a man and a boy. Don't get me wrong. Jacob can be sweet, when he can see past his own wants and needs. But Edward, his complete devotion to Bella, that is the true mark of true love.

Spoken like a true Sister of the HH.....

[SweetImpakt]

I don't understand people switching teams, just because of the movie and Taylor's abs. I mean, OK they are impressive, but that doesn't change a thing about Jake's character right.
Team Edward all the way, I won't ever change my team, absolutely not.

Jacob CAN indeed be a nice guy, but not for Bella.
I love Edward

[KdAliceCullen]

Edward cuz the dogs stink! LOL

[QuileuteLegend]

For me, I definitely think Jacob. Edward is just so... serious. I would feel so awkward around him. It would be like going out with a god. How could I ever trust myself to do the right thing? I would feel like such a little girl next to him. I bet he would see right through me. Jacob, on the other hand, seems easier to get on with. He's closer to my age, and he's more laid-back than Edward. I still doubt I could ever be good enough for him, but I feel like his easy-going personality would put me at ease. I feel like I could actually talk to him and be with him. Plus, I don't think I could deal with Edward reading my mind all the time. Ugh. (And not one mention of Lautner's abdomen. Happy now?)

[dazzledBrit]

For me, definitely Jacob (Jacob, not Taylor!!! ). I adore the way Stephanie wrote Bella and Edward's relationship but for me, personally, Jacob would be better. More relaxed, easy to have a joke with....

I don't get people saying they prefer Jacob only after seeing New Moon.... umm, that's Taylor's body on screen. Yes, he's scrummy (if very young) but the character is Jacob as written by SM. I guess maybe they didn't understand the characters in the book???

[vampyre_princess]

I definietly choose Edward, Cause I'm not that tall so I'd look like a bit dropped off Jacob. And to be completely honest I would so rather be with Edward than Jacob... as I hardly feel cold so Jacob hugging me would be horrible... with his body temp running higher than a humans. And I would always choose a vampire over someone who changes into a wolf... sorry I have a fear of wolves.. so it wouldn't work!

[LionandLamb123]

I would definetley choose EDWARD !

[SunnySummerSunshine]

I'd choose Jacob.

He seems like more fun to be around, plus I've always been a dog lover, prince charming's not gonna change that. Charming's just not my type, fun-loving is. XD

[The girlie-wolf]

Easy Easy Easy Easy Easy ! Jacob!!!!!
But Jake is not right for Bella...

[peppermintmeg]

Oh, Jacob! Of course! To me, Edward is too moody and tortured. I like my men fun and full of life!