Page 6 of 49
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 12:15 am
by debussygirl
About Jane's power...
did this come from a reliable source? Because we may not even have to worry about it.
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 12:52 am
by addictedbooklover
^I think it came from the leaked New Moon script, not sure if that was the genuine article or just somebody's fake one.
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 9:12 am
by redmist
~*~Emily~*~ wrote:
But what really bugged me was this statement:"The movie will be better then the book" ....Better? BETTER? blasphemy!
Totally agree,I mean when has anyone ever made a movie that was better than the book it was based on?I can't recall a single one to be honest.
I seriously hope they don't start throwing in unwarranted and needless (not to mention inaccurate!) 'Edward' scenes to try and appease the 'raging hormone' demographic....
I await with bated breath.....
Cheers,
Tony.
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 1:18 pm
by debussygirl
redmist wrote:~*~Emily~*~ wrote:
But what really bugged me was this statement:"The movie will be better then the book" ....Better? BETTER? blasphemy!
Totally agree,I mean when has anyone ever made a movie that was better than the book it was based on?I can't recall a single one to be honest.
Tuck Everlasting.
At least to me.
But, no way could New Moon the movie be better than the book!!
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 4:02 pm
by ~*~Emily~*~
debussygirl wrote:redmist wrote:~*~Emily~*~ wrote:
But what really bugged me was this statement:"The movie will be better then the book" ....Better? BETTER? blasphemy!
Totally agree,I mean when has anyone ever made a movie that was better than the book it was based on?I can't recall a single one to be honest.
Tuck Everlasting.
At least to me.
True.Also A Walk To Remember,and LOTR..but anyway yeah,A movie just can't totally live up to the experience of reading the book.
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 8:58 pm
by sarah!
~*~Emily~*~ wrote:debussygirl wrote:redmist wrote:~*~Emily~*~ wrote:
But what really bugged me was this statement:"The movie will be better then the book" ....Better? BETTER? blasphemy!
Totally agree,I mean when has anyone ever made a movie that was better than the book it was based on?I can't recall a single one to be honest.
Tuck Everlasting.
At least to me.
True.Also A Walk To Remember,and LOTR..but anyway yeah,A movie just can't totally live up to the experience of reading the book.
Aw, I loved Tuck Everlasting!
The movie was great!
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 8:59 pm
by debussygirl
^^Yeah, the movie was good. The book was creepy.
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 9:01 pm
by sarah!
Yeah it was!
And the ending was so depressing.
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Mon May 18, 2009 3:41 am
by The Dark Knight
debussygirl wrote:redmist wrote:~*~Emily~*~ wrote:
But what really bugged me was this statement:"The movie will be better then the book" ....Better? BETTER? blasphemy!
Totally agree,I mean when has anyone ever made a movie that was better than the book it was based on?I can't recall a single one to be honest.
Tuck Everlasting.
At least to me.
But, no way could New Moon the movie be better than the book!!
Actually the book "Do androids dream of electric sheep," The book Blade Runner was based on. Truly Blade Runner is soooo much better
Re: New Moon movie, take 5
Posted: Mon May 18, 2009 4:53 am
by Dovrebanen
Okay, so yes it has happened that a movie is better than the book. But I find it to happen like once every ten years or so. Maybe LOTR, simply because the movies are easier to follow. There is absolutely no way that the movie NM will be better than the book. We saw Twilight....That pretty much says it all for me. It is still Summit making NM, that has not changed even if it's a new director. So I think it will be better than Twilight, but never in a million years better than the book.
I just don't see how the pain can translate onto the big screen well. Like when she goes under after realizing that her pictures are gone, and doesn't really resurface for months. It was so excellently written.