Lioness Rampant wrote:I disagree with those who say she has depth. She disgusted me in B.D.
The way that she disregarded Bella's life.
When I look at her, I used to see her sad history. Now I see how little value she places on those around her. She is self-centered. She doesn't care about Bella's life. eveything revolves around her and she can get any thing she wants.
Even her relationship with Emmett! She saved him not because she loved him- but because he reminded her of what she always wanted.
Ugh, I hate her character. Her personality is shallow and even Edward agrees.
Bella is just a resource for her- a way for her to get what she wants.
I can NOT relate to that. Sorry.
malaz wrote:I was rereading a part of Breaking Dawn yesterday and something struck me. Is Rosalie just another character looking bad because OF Bella. I have no aversion to Rosalie whatsoever unlike many people, however, I just found it kind of interesting. I mean, is it even Rosalie’s fault if Bella died after giving birth, isn’t that sort of selfish of Bella and not selfish of Rosalie. Because logically, Bella was the one that asked Rosalie to help her keep the baby. It wasn’t like Rosalie was pulling Bella’s leg, and threatening her to keep the baby, even. So how is it that everyone is hating on her. Is it so wrong of her to want to help bella with her child. And the whole thing with Rosalie caring about the baby more than Bella - isn’t that WHAT bella cares about too and wants?
Because for me, certainly I can not see that ‘horrid’ and ‘selfish’ part of Rosalie that is making everyone hating her...
but i guess that's just my oponion
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests