Immy93 wrote:I would have loved it if something had happened before between Edward and Tanya!
A one night or something!
I'm not saying he should have cheated on bella but before he knew her!
It would have really put some drama in the book and put a rocket under Bella's backside!
I thought it was good that Tanya was nice though!
It made me wonder why Edwrad turned her down and why he was so attracted Bella in the first place!
Does anyone agree?
Nerd wrote:I thought Irina did what she did just to be cruel and get even, but that apparently wasn't the entire reason. Her past and her pain...
Babygirl67 wrote:i think at first they were a little judgemental of bella.
edward4ever wrote:But don't you remember?...Edward was that guy. He believed that 'love' and 'lust' held the same place in his heart. He could never have a "thing" with Tanya because she was just interested in the lust she had for Edward. She was a true incubus. "The original" (Her words!). Sure, she was beautiful to him. He had met many beautiful women in his life, but it wasn't just physical beauty that attracted Edward to Bella. It had to touch him on an emotional level as well. He wasn't the "one night stand" kind of guy. And he wasn't looking for it. He thought his life was complete in and of itself. He didn't feel he was missing anything until he fell in love with Bella.
That's what makes his love for Bella that much more powerful! He never felt lust/love for anyone but Bella. His love (and Bella's) transcends the normal human emotions we all have towards other people.
So, a fling between Edward and Tanya (although entertaining to us) would have been wrong on so many levels.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests