holdingoutforjacob wrote:Malaz, he just wasn't that bad.
He did a few stupid things, yes. But haven't you ever known a seventeen year old boy? I'm going to guess you have. I'm also going to guess that you don't think that all of them are crude and unnecessarily mean. Jacob reacted like any normal seventeen year old faced with his set of circumstances would, far better in some ways.
I just don't see how he was mean. To Edward, maybe, but Edward had it coming.
navarre wrote:Whoa - love your banner!! Great six pack on Taylor - he is definitely ready to get his wolf on!!
I do not want anymore POV's. I would love for her to carry on these stories from a third person narrative as most books are written. That way we get everyone's thoughts, so forth. As I have said in previous posts, I never had a problem with the whole Jacob/Renesmee imprinting thing - I was cool with it. Since we already had a Quil/Claire thing, why not Jacob/Renesmee. And yes, I think they can have children. If you think about it that could really unite the pack to the vampires even more in alliances and yes, probably create a new race of beings.
buffygrl3 wrote:I think we can all agree that both Jacob and Edward did their share of stupid things...
In all reality the blame for his somewhat rash actions can be placed on both him, Edward and Bella.
holdingoutforjacob wrote:i am saying that ALL, yes ALL, seventeen year old boys have the occasional jerkish moment. and i'm also saying that Jacob was under a hell of a lot more stress than most boys who are 17.
I just don't understand what, exactly, he did that was so unthinkable. You keep referring to "what Jacob did" as if there's some huge incident or series of incidents that were almost criminal.
You want to talk about an incident that was almost criminal, we can. I really think you need to put him back into focus Malaz, back next to your dear Edward. There are a few things that Edward did that were unthinkable. Like vandalism, and breaking and entering.
SenorGimp wrote:(exasperated) Here we go again *ducks head for protection* jk
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests