threethings wrote:Alright, so I'm thinking more and more, and I think maybe a debate would be good.
Like "The Edward Vs. Jacob debate of 2009", where we would set a date, and everybody show up to debate why they are their team. Discuss weaknesses and strengths, and likes and dislikes.
And It might give us a chance to fill up some pages, yes?
Maybe, what does everybody think?
In the meantime, here's a new question:
When do Jacob and Edward really accept each others in your mind?
Chloe : )
I think that Edward was reluctantly accepting Jacob from the tent scene forward. Only because he was able to recognize the importance of Jacob in Bella's life and just the way he spoke to Jacob. Jacob, for his part in that scene called him "Edward" instead of "bloodsucker" - maybe not so much as accept but a very temporary truce.
But, the whole accepting of each other was in Breaking Dawn. I feel Renesmee's birth and subsequent imprint help to usher in the quieter relationship between Edward & Jacob. Jacob's focus was no longer on Bella, even though it was now on Renesmee' it was not a perverted situation, just a protector situation. Personalities and everything changed - permanently.