1. Are Charlie's feelings toward Edward justified?
i think charlie feels the way he feels because he saw how much bella was torn apart and destroyed by him, and doesnt want him to have that power over her again. he beleives that since bella began hanging out with jacob, she got over edward, and him comeing back only ruined what he saw as the saving grace for his daughter and setting her up for heartbreak again. to be fair, edward did hurt bella more then anyone thought capable, and as a father, charlies only thought and concern is to keep her safe and happy. as a man, he thinks in black and white. ( for lack of better word, simply. at lest thats how i perceive his charector ) he sees edward as the reason bella was shattered and jacob as the reason she was put back together. so when edward comes bak and ruins jacobs and bellas relationship, charlie sees only the black and white and hates edward.
2. Have you ever had a parent disapprove of a relationship?
yes. and lets just say id rather have charlie as a father, and face vicroria alone then have my parents right now
3. Describe your thoughts about Jacobs's message to Bella
first off, ( cynical me kicking in, beware!! ) isnt it kinda strange that instead of just throwing out the paper and writeing each new line on a new paper, he keeps the same paper amd scratches them out? isnt the reason that he scratched them out because they where wrong and he didnt want to tell her that? weird...anyway,a i think jacob is being stubborn and slightly mean. hes lashing out at bella because he wants her and he knows deep down that shell never want him too.
4. Do you feel Edward was being unreasonable in not wanting Bella to go to La Push?
slightly. he is concerned about her safety so much that hes willing to make her unhappy inorder to make her safe. he can tell how much it hurts her to not c jacob, yet he does it still. werwolves are unperdictable, so he has a valid point. and on a few occasions, bella has been in grave danger from them, more then ever the cullens.
5. Do your Dad and his best friend gossip like old women?
naww. they just sit around, drink beers, make jokes and whine about their wives