pharmer4 wrote:really? Her clothes need criticizing? Wow.
I know some people have not liked the manerisms she used in the film but ask yourself, how are you going to convey on film, without narration, how much Edward "dazzles" her, without weird mannerisms like the stop-start and hand gestures like that? And honestly, if someone drops a bombshell on you, such as "soul mate --> leaving town" then you are going to be stuck for words.
The green button down shirt should be burned. Awful.
I see your point, pharmer4. It's complicated to work in a role which is from the protagonist POV, so she didn't have much to work with. What annoyed me, especially on the meadow scene, it was the fact she looked terrified of Edward, untill he asks her if she is afraid of him and she says "No". So, why all the panting and biting lip stuff? You get what I mean? Bad direction. Kristen Stewart is not a bad actress. But she has to have a good director guiding her. But the major flaws in the Twilight movie were bad directing and bad plot. WTH Melissa did with the Meadow scene? I can't conform myself with that.