TNO wrote:I think it would have been awesome if they fell in love, and then Jake imprinted on Renesmee- but recognized that his relationship with Leah was much healthier than any romantic relationship he could have with the newborn, and resisted the imprint in order to stay with Leah. I would have forgiven Meyer for breaking her own canon with the Dhampir thing if she had done something like that.
TNO wrote:^^Of course, flaws are what makes a good character. Sure, Leah was out of line yelling at a sick pregnant woman. She probably knew that. However, she did it anyway because she let her temper get the better of her, which is something I can actually relate to (heh...). And she had a point- from her view, she saw Bella getting everything Bella wanted, and she was maybe even a little jealous and angry at Bella, who she viewed as a spoiled brat.
Pendragon wrote: I think when Smeyer said that the relationship between Jake and Leah surprised her, she should have rolled with in instead of be so persistent to make Jake imprint on Nessie.
suzzeeQ wrote:Pendragon wrote: I think when Smeyer said that the relationship between Jake and Leah surprised her, she should have rolled with in instead of be so persistent to make Jake imprint on Nessie.
I agree. Jacob no longer fit his Forever Dawn ending; his character was too big. She had to squish him to fit his original ending, so much so that he was barely recognizable. He was just a side character in FD. In BD he was a main character. He deserved a way better ending than he got.
Landiana wrote:i think that the relationship between Leah and Jacob alwaya had a foundation because of the fact that they were both stuck in sucky situations. i mean, misery does love company. but the friendship that grew was a surprise to me, the fact that it grew so intense that Leah felt the need to shout at Bella. i think that is the protective side of Leah comming out, because she is older than Jacob and has been around most of his life. in some ways i do feel that she was justified in what she did, she just had bad timing.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests