pennybug84 wrote:For the most part I liked Jacob in NM, he was okay. It wasn't until Eclipse that his attitude, and immature stupid teenage boy behavior really bugged me. So I'm all with you there. I liked him a little better in BD, but only a little. And seriously Edward is just so awesome, sweet, romantic, unselfish and a gentleman.
That was pretty much the way it was for me too. I liked Jacob in NM. He was a good friend for Bella in a time when she really needed him. And I believe when she says that she doesn't know what Edward would have come home to if it hadn't been for Jacob. And then he sort of messed it up when he was trying to make Bella not go to Italy to save Edward. And when he couldn't be happy for her when Alice came to visit. He had to be the crabby wolf.... I didn't like him much in Eclipse. The two kisses were almost unforgivable. And then he redeemed himself at the end of BD. But all the way up until Nessie was born, he did a lot of bad moves.
pennybug84 wrote:I have a question I've been thinking about. If Edward could read Bella's mind, do you think he still would have left in NM?
I actually think that he would. I know that he didn't realize just how deeply she loved him, and that he would have if he could read her mind. But I still think he would have tried. He needed to give her a chance to live without him. He saw his world as bad for her. He didn't want to put her into any danger. And his own brother had just tried to kill her. So I think he would have left no matter what.