Miss seeing the names Shan(n)on around here! *cough*hint-Shannon-hint*cough*
And Mez..I did some more searching and found the quesiton, well more of just a deiscussion, I was thinking of..But guess where I found it..Not even in EDC..The Rosalie Hale discussion thread form back in January!
Well it had this awesome big discussion between me, eclipserox, gossipgirl, and probably some others..
So I'm gonna post my answer to that and then some of the other opinions I liked form the discussion..(I'm always quoting my parts and I will say if they aren't)
If Rosalie could change back into a human, but had to give up Emmett, would she do it?
I think he initial resonse would be to say yes. But then she would think about it.
If she were able to just pick up and leave everything, including Emmett, I don't think she would realise just how good or how strong her love for Emmett was until she left it. I think that Emmett is exactly what Rosalie needs - even if she doesn't know it -and she wouldn't realise this until she left it all behind her, and then I think she may suffer and actually look back and re-assess her decisions as a result and find where she went wrong, and then I think she may regret.
I just don't think Rose realises how much she needs Emmett to ground her and how much happier he makes her (yes, she would also be very happy if she were human and was able to have a baby, but I just think Emmett is what she truly need in her life) until it is too late.
I know everyone says, and Rose says briefly that she would give up everything to be human again..But I don't think she realises what she would be leaving in Emmett if she was given the chance.
In Dark High Noon, Edward is talking about how he is changed completely - that he is changed as much as Carlisle with Esme and Rose with Emmett..So she has a very very strong bond with him and I don't think she can just 'walk' away and leave him behind. She has a very strong love for him and I just don't thin kshe could walk away from him.
(Sorry if they repeat things..They're from different posts and I couldn't be bothered editing them..)
OK that's all I can find wihtout spending too much time on it when i should be writing my report for the month..So I'll leave it there.
But in short, no I don't think Rose would leave Emmett given the chance. I think if she properly weighed all the pros and cons she would find that the pros heavily out weigh the cons and her need for Emmett, whether she consciously is aware of it or not, is too strong for her to just leave it behind.
Aaaaaaaand now I'm off to write my report..I will keep this opened so I can check in..
OH MY GOD OH MY GOD! Guess what!!! Taylor Swift is coming to Australia next February and I'M PROBABLY GOING TO SEE HER!!! I AM SO EXCITED!!!!!!!
I saw the ad for it on the internet today and quickly wrote to mum begging and then we started organising..SO EXCITED!!!!