Total Twilight Fan wrote:Wasnt Jasper meant to have left with Rosalie before the Graduation? He is a year older than Edward, Alice and Bella, and is in the same year as Emmett and Rosalie? Or am i wrong?
GrayceM wrote:I think I posted this under another forum but there's a deal with the engagement ring that bothered me. Edward asks Bella why she isn't wearing her ring and she said that she didn't want to risk losing it (but he knows that it's so Jacob doesn't see it)...but then at the end, she tells him she's going to need the ring and he has it in his pocket ready to put it on her finger.
It seemed strange at the time for him to ask her why she wasn't wearing it, but it sort of flowed with the movie, so I didn't think much about it until the end.
Come to think of it...in the book, he actually propsed when he first showed her the ring so why did she give the ring back in the first place? I mean, she'd already agreed to marry him...
MiVidaLoca wrote:Or when Edward pulls up behind Jake when she hit him and he kissed her. How did Edward even know what had happened yet. Alice wouldn't have seen anything.
Maybe these things could be explained but I don't think it flowed well with what we know.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests