corona wrote:Here is one thing I wouldn’t call necessarily a contradiction, but something that just doesn’t add up in my mind, and that is Heidi and her practice of regularly herding victims into the tower. The group Bella saw was about 40 people; with a feeding every two weeks that comes to over 1,000 people per year, and over 10,000 people over the last decade. People do disappear, yes, but that many people in regular groups of 40 at a time? And nothing is known about it, nobody in the entire world has ever put together a stunning pattern of groups of 40 people disappearing every two weeks like clockwork for decades on end? Groups that include children? Missing human reports that spike every two weeks, all with a group tour or vacation prize connection? Wow. Sorry, that is absolutely impossible.
corona wrote:Well, SM did as good of a job as she possibly could with the others, but the Volturi were always going to present a problem of feeding a lot of vampires without detection. True, this isn’t an actual contradiction, just another gap that wasn’t filled in by the Guide, though I was very interested in Heidi’s bio to see what would be attempted. In the end, SM can't avoid something that every vamp author is eventually guilty of, which is portraying humans as clueless cattle at some point.
BTW, does anyone in the Twi universe work harder for less compensation than Heidi? An eternity of bringing humans to the lazy duff Volturi, working 24/7/365, all for a couple hours every few weeks of being able to wear a cloak that was dyed a few shades darker that the regular guard? And then she’s back on the road again. That is one crappy job.
suzzeeQ wrote:Did Sam graduate high school? The TSG said he only attended the high school on the rez. But it said that Leah graduated from the high school on the rez. He was nineteen in Twilight so I assumed that he graduated.
suzzeeQ wrote:Did Sam graduate high school?
smitten_by_twilight wrote:The Guide carries over something I noticed looking at the Lexicon's timeline: Jasper was only with Maria about 68 years, although he tells Bella in Eclipse that it was almost a century.
vermishelle wrote:If the author wanted for Jasper to leave Maria in 1938, then, to fit the information from “Eclipse”, the timeline should have been as follows: Peter is transformed in 1930 (not 1920) – Charlotte is transformed in 1932 (not 1938) – they run away in 1933 – Peter comes back for Jasper in 1938 and Jasper leaves with him.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest