Chapter 24: Surprise

Our chapter by chapter discussion of Breaking Dawn.

Moderators: Bronze Haired Girl, una

Forum rules
Click for Forum Rules

Re: Chapter 24: Surprise

Postby misskiley » Thu Mar 18, 2010 11:01 pm

1. The tentative friendship between Bella and Rosalie has survived Renesmee’s arrival intact. Why do you think Rosalie is more tolerant of Bella since Bella still went ahead with the change? Do you agree with Bella when she says it’s because she’d finally made the same choice that Rosalie would have made if she was in the same position?
Eh, that's hard to say. Possibly, Rosalie realized Bella could have just as easily killed the baby and went along with her life, but when Bella became pregnant, that was her first priority. Maybe because Bella ended up not giving up anything in the end.

2. Bella is happy and somewhat amazed that she is still very much “herself,” even after the change, like her hatred of surprises. Did you have any expectations that Bella’s personality would be altered, that she would be irrevocably changed in all ways?
Of course,.. I thought she'd be blood thirsty.. not completely normal almost. Not a ton has changed really about Bella and her emotions.. she just gets all the perks of being a vampire.

3. Esme went to great lengths to give Bella and Edward a place of their own. What was your reaction to the cottage?
Wasn't expecting it at all! It was so nice and sweet, of course, just like Esme. It was perfect,.. giving them alone time but not being very far away.

4. Some interesting desires come to surface during this chapter. Were you expecting Bella and Edward to be so drawn in by them or were you expecting them to be more in control? Were you shocked to learn about the other members of the family and their lack of control?
I think they've practiced plenty of control! With as strong of feelings Bella gets whenever Edward touches her, I couldn't believe they even came back from hunting.. I think they've got it down perfect. Rosalie and Emmett is not a surprise at all.. they just seem sex crazed ahah.

5. Bella fears that Edward will miss her humanness. When she confronts him, he initially dances around answering the question. Do you believe that Edward really doesn’t miss it? Do you think he has some regrets or misgivings?

I think Edward is completely happy .. more than happy actually. But of course, he got so used to it. He has said before that her heartbeat was the singlemost important thing in his life.. something he could pick up on from miles away.. Of course he'll miss seing her blush and be clumsy,.. but really.. he won't be kissing the most delicious smelling dinner anymore :)
misskiley
Jump Starting Bella's Truck
 
Posts: 171
Joined: Tue Jan 12, 2010 10:01 pm

Re: Chapter 24: Surprise

Postby Gochiruzeru » Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:56 pm

1. The tentative friendship between Bella and Rosalie has survived Renesmee’s arrival intact. Why do you think Rosalie is more tolerant of Bella since Bella still went ahead with the change? Do you agree with Bella when she says it’s because she’d finally made the same choice that Rosalie would have made if she was in the same position?

I think that Rosalie had already come to accept that Bella was going to change, and now that Bella has had Renesmee, she feels that Bella isn't throwing her life away completely.

2. Bella is happy and somewhat amazed that she is still very much “herself,” even after the change, like her hatred of surprises. Did you have any expectations that Bella’s personality would be altered, that she would be irrevocably changed in all ways?

No, I knew she'd still be the same Bella.

3. Esme went to great lengths to give Bella and Edward a place of their own. What was your reaction to the cottage?

I thought it was really nice of Esme, and I really liked it! It sounded beautiful.

4. Some interesting desires come to surface during this chapter. Were you expecting Bella and Edward to be so drawn in by them or were you expecting them to be more in control? Were you shocked to learn about the other members of the family and their lack of control?

I didn't really think much of it, to be honest. And I had already heard of the houses that Rosalie and Emmett busted, so I wasn't surprised.

5. Bella fears that Edward will miss her humanness. When she confronts him, he initially dances around answering the question. Do you believe that Edward really doesn’t miss it? Do you think he has some regrets or misgivings?

I think he somewhat misses the scent, since it was really nice, but all in all, he likes the fact that she's a vampire.
User avatar
Gochiruzeru
Jump Starting Bella's Truck
 
Posts: 130
Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:49 am
Location: Pennsylvania

Re: Chapter 24: Surprise

Postby Tornado » Sun Jun 26, 2011 6:14 am

1. The tentative friendship between Bella and Rosalie has survived Renesmee’s arrival intact. Why do you think Rosalie is more tolerant of Bella since Bella still went ahead with the change? Do you agree with Bella when she says it’s because she’d finally made the same choice that Rosalie would have made if she was in the same position?
I think that is the reason. And Rosalie is now an aunt to an actual child, which is probably something she wanted but never expected to have. So that has helped her with all the things she felt she had missed out on too. Now Bella is responsible for giving that to her.

2. Bella is happy and somewhat amazed that she is still very much “herself,” even after the change, like her hatred of surprises. Did you have any expectations that Bella’s personality would be altered, that she would be irrevocably changed in all ways?
No, I thought she'd be pretty much the same.

3. Esme went to great lengths to give Bella and Edward a place of their own. What was your reaction to the cottage?
I thought it was gorgeous!

4. Some interesting desires come to surface during this chapter. Were you expecting Bella and Edward to be so drawn in by them or were you expecting them to be more in control? Were you shocked to learn about the other members of the family and their lack of control?
Nope. I thought it was all quite entertaining!

5. Bella fears that Edward will miss her humanness. When she confronts him, he initially dances around answering the question. Do you believe that Edward really doesn’t miss it? Do you think he has some regrets or misgivings?
No, I don't think so. He was sad because he thought that she'd hate the vampire life, but she's doing so well, I think it's filling him with hope. And he always knew that this change would be easier on him. Now he doesn't have to be careful, and his throat isn't on fire all the time.
Image
Tornado
Playing a Duet With Edward
 
Posts: 2995
Joined: Sat Jun 18, 2011 7:06 pm
Location: The Land Down Under

Re: Chapter 24: Surprise

Postby Brienna » Mon Jul 18, 2011 9:47 am

1. The tentative friendship between Bella and Rosalie has survived Renesmee’s arrival intact. Why do you think Rosalie is more tolerant of Bella since Bella still went ahead with the change? Do you agree with Bella when she says it’s because she’d finally made the same choice that Rosalie would have made if she was in the same position?
Even though Rose isn't the mother of Renesmee, Bella 'gave' Rose a baby to care for. By making the choice Bella made, she not only made the choice Rose would have made, but also made Rose's wish come true: 'a baby'. Rose also understands that Bella couldn't survive if she wasn't changed, so she accepts that Bella's changed now.

2. Bella is happy and somewhat amazed that she is still very much “herself,” even after the change, like her hatred of surprises. Did you have any expectations that Bella’s personality would be altered, that she would be irrevocably changed in all ways?
No, I didn't think that she would change.

3. Esme went to great lengths to give Bella and Edward a place of their own. What was your reaction to the cottage?
I thought it was very sweet!

4. Some interesting desires come to surface during this chapter. Were you expecting Bella and Edward to be so drawn in by them or were you expecting them to be more in control? Were you shocked to learn about the other members of the family and their lack of control?
Nope, no shock here :lol: I figured they would be drawn into those desires :lol:

5. Bella fears that Edward will miss her humanness. When she confronts him, he initially dances around answering the question. Do you believe that Edward really doesn’t miss it? Do you think he has some regrets or misgivings?
I think he's still not happy about the fact itself that Bella is a vampire now. He wanted her to have a human life.
Image
User avatar
Brienna
Finding a Nice Guy for Angela
 
Posts: 997
Joined: Wed Jun 30, 2010 8:32 am
Location: The Netherlands

Previous

Return to A Perfect Piece of Forever

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron