I think what is really missing from the picture is any demonstration that Jacob understands that Edward and Bella are actually the parents. That would have helped a lot.
Openhome wrote:Okay, I love this series and all -- and I even liked Breaking Dawn -- but that line, "my brother, my son" made me burst out laughing so hard I spit my gum into the book. That has to be one of the corniest lines ever published.
My biggest problem with Jacob imprinting on Renesmee is the fact that he becomes more like the father figure to her instead of Edward. I could be misunderstanding Jacob's role in her life, but I felt like Edward was not as close to his daughter as he should be - that Jacob sort of assumed that role.
These events are necessary to the plot so they are the ones we get to see, but there's every reason to believe that Edward spends time with his daughter, we just don't see it. Jake's role would be similar to the relationship Quil has with Claire, I'd say.
As for the issue of people having their choices taken away from them, I don't really think it applies. All the imprinters and imprintee's seem blissfully happy with their individual circumstances.
Tornado wrote:But do they need another option? If they imprint on the person who is best for them why waste time on another relationship?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests