Twilight Lexicon Discussion Forums

After finally rereading the Book and seeing the film 5 times, here is my rather long review/analysis of New Moon. What do you think? One of the things I was curious about was how accurate an adaption this movie would be. Chapter by Chapter Voice-over narration - by Kristen is right from the book (q...

AshleyO~ I agree completely. When you are so used to having that insight, it is hard to take into account that Kristen can't ever be as explicit in terms of what she is experiencing as Bella as we would like. It's not like we can always have a running narration like we get in the book. Also, I hone...

I've seen it twice, too. And its still only okay, for me. I don't think I'll need to see it again, can't take any more of Robert. >.< I took about ten sticky notes worth of notes so I could remember everything. Yeah, I'm insane. Impressions upon the second time seeing: Kirsten needs to wear a bra w...

I understand why they put 2 scenes from the book together for the Meadow, but it still irks me. They rushed the romance. Rob and Kristen did what they could with what they were given, but it would have been so much better if they were given more time. Dark Muse you are so right. On your first point...

I can't decide between the "it wouldn't be like drinking your blood, for instance" line and the meadow. They were both just...wrong. It must have killed Rob to say that line.... Edward would never in a million years have said something like that. He was ashamed of his nature. He would hav...

Loved the contact colours this time around and the fact that the camera didn't have to be right in the actors face to show the colour. Only wished that Alice had black eyes when she visited Bella, and that Edward had black eyes when they were in Italy, and well, I wish the Guard had more of a darke...

All I can say is WOWZA!!!!!!!! Second showing was even better than the first. I noticed a few more things, even though my brain was still completely overloaded. I cannot even express how much I absolutely adore RobWard. He totally owns my soul in this film. Rob Pattinson owns me in this film... his...

Hey Everyone! Like the rest of you, I am still in awe at how good this movie was. I'm going again tonight with the hubs. :-) Here are some random thoughts/questions I have. One funny story is when Jake first took his shirt off when Bella hit her head, there was some oos and aaahs and whistles. Well...

in this particualr dissousion i have to agree mosty with navarre alltough i quite liked how rob potrayed edward, i didn't feel he was the edward i knew from the book. I didn't like kristen in the role at all, i felt this was some of her worst acting..and she is normally really good...i felt she was...