Search found 2171 matches

by holdingoutforjacob
Sat Apr 10, 2010 2:42 pm
Forum: Quench Your Thirst
Topic: Imprinting
Replies: 654
Views: 136216

Re: Imprinting

Well, I don't think she can "get better" until she can answer those questions completely, but I agree with you that she's certainly working through the Sam/Emily pain. Oy, I read your response incorrectly... I thought you said she couldn't imprint because she was in so much pain, so disregard everyt...
by holdingoutforjacob
Sat Apr 10, 2010 1:39 pm
Forum: Quench Your Thirst
Topic: Imprinting
Replies: 654
Views: 136216

Re: Imprinting

What BD did you read?? In the one I read, she was happier, less tortured, but she still had all those questions and all that pain. I wish imprinting was based on whether or not it would be painful for you to imprint or whether it's the right thing for you, individually, but it's apparently not, or e...
by holdingoutforjacob
Sat Apr 10, 2010 1:35 pm
Forum: Sparkling in the Sun
Topic: Bella Swan Cullen #3
Replies: 681
Views: 156905

Re: Bella Swan Cullen #3

You know, you could have just asked me where I got that information - which was in the book, not the movie, actually - without the sarcasm. Yes, Bella HAD already fallen for Edward when she met Jacob, in Chapter 6, Scary Stories. She took the walk with him to get more information. That doesn't mean ...
by holdingoutforjacob
Sat Apr 10, 2010 1:07 pm
Forum: Quench Your Thirst
Topic: Imprinting
Replies: 654
Views: 136216

Re: Imprinting

I don't know that she's happy. Leah, more than anyone else, has had her chances of happiness and a healthy relationship destroyed by imprinting. Not only will she always have to question why she's the only girl who's ever turned, she'll also have to question why she hasn't imprinted yet, or if she c...
by holdingoutforjacob
Sat Apr 10, 2010 12:11 pm
Forum: Quench Your Thirst
Topic: Favorite Book of the Saga
Replies: 193
Views: 71982

Re: Favorite Book of the Saga

I think Eclipse is the best, and also the most well-written. It has some of everything. It has a lot of Jacob, who I actually like in this book the best (I know, I'm the only one) and it shows both Edward's flaws and his strengths, as opposed to the eternally glowing view we usually get from Bella. ...
by holdingoutforjacob
Sat Apr 10, 2010 12:07 pm
Forum: Quench Your Thirst
Topic: Imprinting
Replies: 654
Views: 136216

Re: Imprinting

Well, just to add my two cents. I would hate it if Leah imprinted, even more than I hated Jacob imprinting - which was a lot. It's true that it would take away her pain, and I guess ignorance is bliss, but it would be dissatisfying to the reader, definitely.
by holdingoutforjacob
Fri Apr 09, 2010 9:54 pm
Forum: Sparkling in the Sun
Topic: Bella Swan Cullen #3
Replies: 681
Views: 156905

Re: Bella Swan Cullen #3

Again, I understand perfectly well what she was trying to say, but it was irrelevant to what I was saying. Originally, Jazz said that Bella was never in love with Jacob, which is untrue. SM has stated very very clearly that she fell in love with him in New Moon. But, thanks for trying to help! :D Th...
by holdingoutforjacob
Fri Apr 09, 2010 5:11 pm
Forum: Quench Your Thirst
Topic: Imprinting
Replies: 654
Views: 136216

Re: Imprinting

She was gone for like five years, and she's dealt with her mother's death and she's lived a life somewhere else. Of course she's different. Everyone changes in the span of five years, especially young adults. Granted, we don't really know anything about her beforehand.
by holdingoutforjacob
Thu Apr 08, 2010 10:25 pm
Forum: Sparkling in the Sun
Topic: Bella Swan Cullen #3
Replies: 681
Views: 156905

Re: Bella Swan Cullen #3

I would think that, if Leah drew that parallel, it would make her hate Bella more. Bella's Sam, if you're going to compare the two situations. She's the one that loves two people. If anything it would make her more compassionate towards Jacob (the one left out, like her) as opposed to Bella (the one...
by holdingoutforjacob
Thu Apr 08, 2010 10:14 pm
Forum: Quench Your Thirst
Topic: Imprinting
Replies: 654
Views: 136216

Re: Imprinting

Paul and Rachel and Jared and Kim are the ones I actually find plausible and kind of sweet. Paul and Rachel could easily have happened, since Rachel left and didn't come back for a long time. I'm assuming she changed in that time. And you hear lots of stories about people suddenly getting a new pers...