Twilight Lexicon Discussion Forums

I liked some parts of Jacob's book but didn't like others. I agree the chapter titles were hilariouos & he was pretty funny with his blonde jokes w/Rosalie and the interaction there. it was kind of nice to see his perspective (especially the relationship with Leah & good old Seth.) and I got to understand him a little better.

but the end where after Bella has given birth to Renesmee and she's unresponsive Jake totally just gives up and walks out of the room . "oh the girl I supposedly love is dying but I'm not going to do anything to help her. I'm giving up. let me walk out of the room & the house now." but yet Edward is still their trying so hard & valiantly to save Bella and make sure she's not going to die & leave him. he never gave up on Bella at all & was able to save her life! so this showed me that yes Bella & Edward are meant to be together, and that Edward loves and cares for Bella MUCH MORE than Jacob ever did.

also I actually didn't catch on at first that he had imprinted on Renesmee. I felt like such a dork later when Bella figure it out & that's when I realized that's what had happened. and to me that's just so weird.

SilentHeart, I agree that Jacob is the only person who could really have told the whole story. He had a bit more perspective and could observe things sort of from a distance instead of being depressed and guilty like Edward or in pain like Bella. It was also interesting knowing how the pack's minds worked.

The best part of Jacob's book would have to be the chapter titles. Gotta love them; they're just so practicle, it's hilarious. :] It was nice to see everything from someone's perspective other than Bella's.

When I ended Bella's first book, I was really disappointed. So I searched for the second part of Bella's book, when I read the first page of it, I realized I had to read Jacob's book first.
I didn't like that in the beginning, because I thought Bella wouldn't come back in his book. But then I read about Bella again. Then I was convinced it was nice to read.

I didn't like it that it was só hárd to imagine how Bella felt. I didn't like it, because I wanted to know what she was feeling, what she was thinking. I didn't like it that Alice couldn't see something either.
But I liked it. Besides this points, I liked to read about Jacob's pack and I loved it when he was talking with the pack.

Yeah, I didn't like it at first sight, but after all it was nice to read. I prefer Bella's books though.

I actually liked Jacob's book. I was surprised because up until I read his book, I never really liked him. But after I got to see how he mature he was, I realized that I sort of liked his character. He was really funny and sweet and the chapter titles were hilarious. I still like Edward better, but reading Jacob's book made me finally appreciate his character a little more.

It was definitely a plus for the book!
Even though I could have used less of his opinions and more of his observations about the situation, I still think it was very enlightening. After all, it is a book on his POV, no way he could have done it without sharing it!
What I really liked about Jacob's book are the Leah and Seth part. If it wasn't for Jacob, we wouldn't have known and loved Seth the way we do. And the best part is that Jacob did such a good job that we pretty much know what we have to know about Seth!

I so agree with you! (I forgot your name, but I mean the one who posted above this post)
I hated him too. And I felt a disgust when I read he was imprinting on Renesmee, I hated him more than I already did.

But when I finished his book I understood him a little bit better. But I hoped; please don't let Jacob has a second book in BD.