Twilight Lexicon Discussion Forums

Yeah I figured they did since you asked. That would have been some Eclipse at least Tent scene, wedding, pregnant and childbirth mixed with Victoria and newborns and everything...

What I would be most looking forward to in Eclipse is the proposal. And also seeing Edward and Seth fighting Victoria and Riley.

so i'm pretty excited to see how BDH portrays victoria...rachell was a great victoria, and i love how enthusiastic she was about Twilight, but hopefully we'll see a new dimension to Victoria in eclipse.

this victoria thing just wrecks it...
like OMG!
jeez.
you can't have 2 different people.
OMG!
they probs don't even have the same voice.
VAMPIRES AREN'T SUPPOSED TO CHANGE! at alll..
wow

I wonder how much Victoria will be in EC. Like in Twilight they added in the nomads more than there was in the book...so are we going to see Victoria or not before the battle?
If there's just the battle, I don't think it will bother as much that they switched actors, but if we're constantly seeing Victoria it may irk me a bit more.

I actually think Riley will be in Eclipse more than just the one scene... maybe shots of him sneaking into Bella's house or whatever... because the big point was that Bella got a the revelation that it was Victoria finally-- so it would make some sense to lead the audience (even though 90% have read the books) into some suspense and not tell them the whole truth.

debussygirl wrote:I wonder how much Victoria will be in EC. Like in Twilight they added in the nomads more than there was in the book...so are we going to see Victoria or not before the battle?
If there's just the battle, I don't think it will bother as much that they switched actors, but if we're constantly seeing Victoria it may irk me a bit more.

i don't think we'll see much of her aside from the battle scene, maybe a few small scenes, like memories and such. But Bella didn't put 2 and 2 together that Victoria was behind the vampire army until right before the battle between edward and victoria. She had to keep a very low profile to avoid alice's vision....then again Melissa Rosenburg didn't give Alice very much credit....Bella was able to just walk out of the hotel in Twilight, so I could be wrong...

So according to the interview Peter gave (posted on the lex) it sounds like we'll actually be watching the newborn battle and it won't only be Edward telling Bella was going on.

What does everyone think about that?

Amanda Beth wrote:So according to the interview Peter gave (posted on the lex) it sounds like we'll actually be watching the newborn battle and it won't only be Edward telling Bella was going on.

What does everyone think about that?

I'm excited, I liked the fight scene in Twilight between James and Edward, so I'm looking forward to see how the battle scene with the new borns and cullens goes...especially since there will be more of a budget for the movie and effects.

So I'm a little worried.
I think Eclipse had a good amount of action, with Edward vs. Victoria. I'm afraid that if they decide to take up time with the Cullens vs. newborns that they'll cut out scenes. Eclipse is already so big, and look at everything that was cut out of Twilight! If they put more action in I think that may over-do it. I absolutely loathe when movies are all action and no plot *cough*GobletofFire*cough*.

I think it would be cool if they did a montage of clips from the battle scene, with edwards voice over, so it's like we see what's going on in his head while he's telling bella. I think that would be a good compromise, that way they don't have to cut scenes to make room for a long drawn out battle scene.