Page 20 of 25
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Mon Apr 06, 2009 3:23 am
by Wolf-Girl90
Lacuna Scion wrote:Jacob.
It's hard because I love Edward, but he really starts to get on my nerves as the saga progresses. I understand how he's perfect for Bella. I wouldn't be as patient as Bella. I wouldn't respond well to his protectiveness or his mood swings. We would be the ultimate dysfunctional couple; we'd be all in love and happy and then I'd be screaming at him and we wouldn't talk for two weeks before we got back together again. I know you know the type 
.
For me, Jacob was always just right. He's obviously protective but he's not ridiculous about it and despite the wolfy tendencies he's very normal. I enjoy that Jacob says and does really stupid things, on occasion. I would develop a major complex if I was always the only one messing things up. I have a compulsive need to help people and there isn't much I could ever do for Edward. I would feel it was all take and no give.
I like a little adventure in my life too and Jacob seems to be able to embrace that without getting hurt (minus the fantasy creature fights). And I'm always so darn cold so his heat would be really nice. I'm also very sarcastic and quite blunt, Jacob shares the same tendency.
Jacob just feels more natural to me. Edward would be like a drug addiction, but Jake's more your favorite food - not something that'll scare you or come back to bite you (no pun intended). I feel like I could be away from him for a while without it causing any major rifts in my life. The power that Edward wields over Bella (totally not his fault, she's just crazy in love ) scares me and I'd always feel on edge.
-Rose
I totally agree! Jacob is totally like your favourite food!
xoxo
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Mon Apr 06, 2009 3:26 am
by Wolf-Girl90
Lacuna Scion wrote:Jacob.
It's hard because I love Edward, but he really starts to get on my nerves as the saga progresses. I understand how he's perfect for Bella. I wouldn't be as patient as Bella. I wouldn't respond well to his protectiveness or his mood swings. We would be the ultimate dysfunctional couple; we'd be all in love and happy and then I'd be screaming at him and we wouldn't talk for two weeks before we got back together again. I know you know the type .
For me, Jacob was always just right. He's obviously protective but he's not ridiculous about it and despite the wolfy tendencies he's very normal. I enjoy that Jacob says and does really stupid things, on occasion. I would develop a major complex if I was always the only one messing things up. I have a compulsive need to help people and there isn't much I could ever do for Edward. I would feel it was all take and no give.
I like a little adventure in my life too and Jacob seems to be able to embrace that without getting hurt (minus the fantasy creature fights). And I'm always so darn cold so his heat would be really nice. I'm also very sarcastic and quite blunt, Jacob shares the same tendency.
Jacob just feels more natural to me. Edward would be like a drug addiction, but Jake's more your favorite food - not something that'll scare you or come back to bite you (no pun intended). I feel like I could be away from him for a while without it causing any major rifts in my life. The power that Edward wields over Bella (totally not his fault, she's just crazy in love ) scares me and I'd always feel on edge.
-Rose
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Mon Apr 06, 2009 6:57 pm
by diane771
Totally Edward. Even though I breed alaskan malamutes, I just can't see them turning into a human.
Edward is a mystery and I like that about a man. Edward thinks about Bella more than himself who wouldn't want a man like that? Jacob is not that way maybe he will be when he imprints on someone. (not talking about Renesemee)
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Fri Apr 10, 2009 5:13 pm
by i am bella
edward, was there really any other option?
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2009 10:46 pm
by Ihavemylion
Edward.... Reasons being:
Edward has all sides to him... Serious, Funny, Romantic, Edgy, Protective, Mature, Old fashion Gentlemen, Cultural, carries himself well, and unselfish. And he wont change into a huge Wolf within Seconds LoL
Jacob is a cutie... I think of him like a kid.... and he has his rude sarcastic side to him. But hes still a good decent person. Just not my type
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 2:57 pm
by Soul&Romance
x3 to Lacuna Scion. You said exactly what I was thinking!
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 4:28 pm
by KikiMasenCullen
Edward Anthony Masen Cullen...
Hands down, pure and simple. Anyone who knows me, knows I'd NEVER choose Jacob. I think that Jacob has this (and I'm quoting Bella in 'Breaking Dawn') "moronic, wolfy claim" on her, and it needs to stop...
Edward...hmm...he's everything in a guy I'd want...I don't mind him watching me while I sleep. I don't mind him being overprotective...and I'd wonder if the "constant banging" as a previous poster would be a bad thing....so definitely Edward...
Mmmm...
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Sat Apr 18, 2009 6:59 pm
by cantfightaneclipse
I would choose Jacob for me because he is less intense it would be so much easier to just be me with. Edward is always staring and is so in love it would start to creep me out and he would constantly be hounding at you about where were you and are you sure you're okay? Edward would drive me insane, so Jacob definitely Jacob. Plus I loved the parts of Eclipse where Jacob kissed Bella they were my favorites!!!
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2009 3:14 pm
by Renesmee101
Jacob, hands down. We match, as strange as that sounds. Its the only way to explain how I feel.
Its like, the way he reacts in the book is how I was reacting in my mind, and the way he says things, and especially the way that he thinks, is really similar to me. But there's also some things we're different on, like his car fanatic-ness. Its all yiddish to me. But seriously, there's something about Jacob that I find very intruiging. And all my friends who've read the series say that Jacobwould be perfect for me if he was real. And I loooved the long hair in Twilight, it would have been so much fun to play with! Plus, Steph's description of him physically is perfection. I always wind up drawn to guys like Jake.
Re: Edward or Jacob, who would you choose for you?
Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2009 7:44 pm
by Twilightchick79
Edward. He is an old soul which matches my personality. To find someone who uncondionally in love with you is an incredible gift. He is romantic, intelligent and a gentleman. I would gladly turn into a vampire for him.
