Peter Facinelli as Carlisle Cullen

[bittenbyEdwardCullen]

The fact that I can only picture Peter Facinelli as Mike Dexter from "Can't Hardly Wait" is tainting my perception of his role as Carlisle. He "looks" the part, but I'll just have to judge for myself when I watch the movie to see if he "acts" the part. Don't get me wrong. I think he's great. He just doesn't seem "Carlisle" to me.

I know what you mean! It's going to be a little strange because now when I see a picture of him as Carlisle I see him as Mike and not the highly educated doctor.

[Venecettia]

I haven't seen ANY of his movies. I saw what he looked like, and thought he did look like Carlisle, but I didn't know how he would act as him. Such as facial expressions and such.

[AliceLauren]

Omg. wow. I thought when I first saw him that mt imagination came to life! He is exactly perfect. He looks EXACTLY like Carlisle in my mind.

I love him. So perfect Carlisle. The director and everybody even make him dress like I imagined Carlisle would.

[nikie_nikz]

James Marsden could have pulled off being Carlisle as well. Or maybe not. He looks less paternal than Peter Facinelli, and would outshine Robert Pattinson in the looks department. Just my opinion

[save-the-wetlands]

James Marsden could have pulled off being Carlisle as well. Or maybe not. He looks less paternal than Peter Facinelli, and would outshine Robert Pattinson in the looks department. Just my opinion

Maybe....he seems to more of an Emmett. But I still like Peter. Henry Cavill was offered the part but turned it down....

[Edward-Bella-forever]

Peter is pretty hot for being in his 30's. Then again it, his appearance fits the role of Carlisle. He'll be great as Carlisle.

[save-the-wetlands]

Peter is pretty hot for being in his 30's. Then again it, his appearance fits the role of Carlisle. He'll be great as Carlisle.

Agreed

[Crooked_Rose]

^Oh yeah...he's a hottie. I remember for that 2 seconds he was in the New Twilight Trailer I was like *drool*

The thing is is that when I was reading Carlisle the first person I thought of was Dr. Robert Chase (Jesse Spencer) from House. LOL

James Marsden! Aw...he's so cute!

[save-the-wetlands]

^Oh yeah...he's a hottie. I remember for that 2 seconds he was in the New Twilight Trailer I was like *drool*

The thing is is that when I was reading Carlisle the first person I thought of was Dr. Robert Chase (Jesse Spencer) from House. LOL

James Marsden! Aw...he's so cute!

Yeah I have that sceencap, its frequently my backgrond on my Zune. He was the July pic in the Twilight calendar.
i first imagined Stephenie's pick Charlie Hunman.

[Wish.I.may]

At first I didn't see him as Carlisle.
Then they released the first three pics of the Cullens and I was : Wow, It's Carlisle.
Then I saw the pic in the calendar.
Then I was like. all over again. :p